Friday, February 15, 2008
VI Conclusions
V Certification Authorities
The main problem posed by legislation on certification authorities is that, unlike most other activities, it is very difficult to restrict it to one country. It is not by chance that one of the most widely ratified international treaties is The Hague Convention for the abolition of legalization that, through the instrument of Apostille, was able to consent the recognition of documents signed and notarized abroad. It is quite clear that the same path cannot be followed with reference to digital signatures. The digital world is so quick that the sole idea of having to go through a recognition process with reference to each signature is unthinkable. On the other hand, it is not easy to agree on an international treaty to insure the validity of an electronic signature certified abroad, however the solution of the problem is vital for the success of e-commerce.
The problem was almost ignored by the German and Italian legislation which have preceded the issuance of the EU Directive. Both Article 4 of the German law and Article 8 of the Italian law provide for a national license as a prerequisite for the issuance of a certification. Nothing is said regarding the validity of digital signatures certified in other countries.
This issue was immediately apparent, however, as soon as the legislative effort moved to a supranational level, i.e. at the EU level. It was also apparent that the certification of digital signatures is a business and, as such, no barriers should be imposed to the free movement of those services within the European Union11. Pursuant to the above approach Article 3 of the Directive sets the principle that Member States shall not make the provision of certification services subject to prior authorization12.
In practice, however, it may be very difficult for the public to ascertain whether a specified certification service provider meets the minimum standards required by the Directive to issue certificates having the effect of validating the signature as Advanced Electronic Signature, and the Directive therefore provides for a voluntary accreditation scheme and for a supervision system.
The rules for the accreditation scheme are dictated by Article 3(2) of the Directive according to which Member States may introduce or maintain voluntary accreditation schemes provided that the conditions to access the scheme be objective, transparent, proportionate and non-discriminatory. The accreditation scheme shall not be limited to a set number of participants.13
The supervision of the certification service provider is delegated to the Member States with reference to the providers established in such a state.
Regarding the free-across the border circulation of the digital signature (with certification), the Directive establishes the important principle of recognition of certifications issued in another Member State, if in conformity with the provisions of the Directive. Member states are also bound to make sure that electronic signature products in compliance with the Directive are permitted to circulate in the internal market.
It is not possible, however, to limit the digital world to the EU, also considering the large presence of USA companies on the market, and Article 7 of the Directive deals with this issue by providing that the certificates issued by a company established outside the EU are recognized within the EU provided that :
a) the certification service provider fulfils the requirements of the Directive and has been accredited under a voluntary accreditation scheme in any of the EU Member States, or
b) the certificate is counter-guaranteed by an EU service provider; or
c) the certificate or the certification service provider is recognized under a bilateral or multilateral treaty.
In practice, either through voluntary accreditation or through an alliance with a European provider, the certification of foreign providers will be recognized in the EU.14
Finally, a few words about the liability of the service providers, which issue is specifically addressed by Article 6 of the Directive under which as a minimum, Member States shall ensure that by issuing a certificate to the public or by guaranteeing such a certificate the certification service provider is liable for damage caused to any party which relied on such a certificate :
a) as regards the accuracy at the time of issuance of all information contained in the qualified certificate and as regards the fact that the certificate contains all the details prescribed for a qualified certificate;
b) for assurance that at the time of issuance of the certificate, the signatory identified in the qualified certificate held the signature creation data corresponding to the signature verification data given or identified in the certificate;
c) for assurance that the signature creation data and the signature verification data can be used in a complementary manner in cases where the certification service provider generates them both, unless the certification service provider proved that he has not acted negligently;
d) in the event the certification service provider did not promptly register the revocation of the certificate.
Advanced Electronic Signatures
The EU Directive intends being technology neutral and does not indicate what type of technological devices should be used to have a secure signature creation device which, however, must utilise appropriate technical and procedural means, to ensure at least that:
(a) the signature-creation-data used for signature generation can practically occur only once, and that their secrecy is reasonably assured;
(b) the signature-creation-data used for signature generation cannot, with reasonable assurance, be derived and the signature is protected against forgery using currently available technology;
(c) the signature-creation-data used for signature generation can be reliably protected by the legitimate signatory against the use of others.
(d) the secure signature-creation devices must not alter the data to be signed or prevent such data from being presented to the signatory prior to the signature process.
The signature must be based on a Qualified Certificate, which is an electronic attestations linking the signature-verification data to a person and confirming the identity of that person, such a certification to be issued by a certification service provider. The Directive prohibits the Member States from making the provision of certification services subject to prior authorisation, although a voluntarily accreditation system is permitted, and sets out the criteria that a certification-service-provider must meet in order to issue qualified certificates pursuant to the Directive.
The qualified certificate must contain certain minimum level or information including:
(a) an indication that the certificate is issued as a qualified certificate;
(b) the identification of the certification-service-provider and the State in which it is established;
(c) the name of the signatory or a pseudonym, which shall be identified as such;
(d) provision for a specific attribute of the signatory to be included if relevant, depending on the purpose for which the certificate is intended;
(e) signature-verification data which correspond to signature-creation data under the control of the signatory;
(f) an indication of the beginning and end of the period of validity of the certificate;
(g) the identity code of the certificate;
(h) the advanced electronic signature of the certification-service-provider issuing it;
(i) limitations on the scope of use of the certificate, if applicable; and
(j) limits on the value of transactions for which the certificate can be used, if applicable.
It will be for the national legislation to decide when this type of advanced electronic signature will be required. The current trend is that of issuing regulation to make e-commerce available to public administrations, considering the usually more stringent, formalistic rules usually applicable to public contracts9. For example, Italy has issued a number of rules to make possible the use of e-based applications in public procurement contract, and plans are under way to eliminate almost completely the recourse to paper certification for a variety of purposes.
Another possible immediate beneficiary of the advanced electronic signature is certainly going to be the banking system. As of today most countries require that the initial contract with the customer be signed in writing on paper. The requirements are even stricter in those countries with stringent anti-laundering control, which often require the personal identification of the customer as well as of its signature by a bank officer or by a notary public. The advanced electronic signature will identify the customer, its signature and some of its personal data, therefore making it possible to offer banking services without having to go through an initial face to face contact. This will be very important especially for banks which do not have a large office network, and which are currently at a disadvantage when trying to convince new client.
Just to make you an example, when I opened a trading on line account with one of the major Italian players in the market, which is not however a major bank with widespread bank offices, I found out that they provided a door to door service for clients who were not located sufficiently close to one of their bank offices, or it would have been almost impossible for them to get new contracts (unless the client really wanted to get an account with them).
Section 5 of Directive 1999/93, provides that
(a) satisfy the legal requirements of a signature in relation to data in electronic form in the same manner as a handwritten signature satisfies those requirements in relation to paper-based data; and
(b) are admissible as evidence in legal proceedings.
2. Member States shall ensure that an electronic signature is not denied legal effectiveness and admissibility as evidence in legal proceedings solely on the grounds that it is:
- in electronic form, or
- not based upon a qualified certificate, or
- not based upon a qualified certificate issued by an accredited certification-service-provider, or
- not created by a secure signature-creation device.
II. Handwritten Signatures v. Digital Signatures
In theory we can have different handwritten signatures for various purposes, we may initial certain documents and use full signature in other documents, however the process and the result is not different. In practice, in the paper world we basically have one definition of signature, which attributes the document to the signing party, and whose effect depends on the type of document, applicable law, etc.
Handwritten signatures have not always had this importance, and in the past the same legal implications was given to official seals, rather than to signatures, and a residue of this has remained in some public law legislation as well as in some more traditional countries.
We can basically say that as soon as writing became common, handwritten signatures became the main method of attributing a document to an individual. At the same time, most legislations considerably disfavoured oral agreements and, as such, signing in writing a contract has become the primary procedure to evidence that each party to a contract was in agreement with it.
Because on the central role of signatures, a special set of rules has been developed in every country to deal with issues such as authentication of signatures, forgery of signatures, etc.. All those rules imply the existence of an handwriting.
The tradition scenario is quite difficult to apply to digital signatures and, basically, we have to start the entire process all over again.
First of all, we have to identify what is the best method for attributing the digital document to a person. This implies that we must be reasonably sure that the process provides some inherent assurance against forgery and frauds. In the paper world the assurance was given by the supposed uniqueness of every person's handwriting, in the digital world we have to decide about a "unique" element that will have the same, or a similar, function.
For example, I normally type my name when sending an e-mail, however this is not sufficient to prove undoubtedly that the e-mail comes from me, as anybody else may type in my name. We may decide that the circumstance that the transmission comes from my computer and that I am the only one to access my computer is sufficient evidence, or require that I encrypt the message with a code known to me and to the recipient, or that I use a signature verified by a cryptographic algorithm disclosed to the recipient, or certified by a third party, or that I use a biometric key, just to mention a few alternatives. The role of the regulation is that of identifying the requirements that, when met, qualify an apparently incoherent electroning signal as my signature and, subsequently, that of deciding what are the legal effects of that electronic signal. Later on the regulation should also identify rules to deal with forgery problems, however we are still far from this point being reasonably addressed.
I. Introduction
The purpose of this paper is that of analysing some of the key legal problems posed by the use of digital signatures. Many legislatures in the world are trying to decide whether they should regulate or not digital signatures, and some countries have decided that some type of regulation is desirable and have either issued or are about to issue appropriate legislation.
As we will see below, the legal issues posed by digital signatures are quite a few and not easy to address, also considering the speed at which the digital world moves and the inherent interplay between legislation and technology developments.
For my analysis, I have decided to concentrate on what I believe are, as of today, some of the main broad issues: scope and validity of a digital signatures, role and liability of Certifying Authorities, recognition of digital signatures in a transaction across the border.
To this purpose, I will mainly examine the European legislative experience, both at EU level and Member States level (mainly Germany, Spain and Italy).
Monday, February 11, 2008
Electronic commerce, commonly known as e-commerce or eCommerce, consists of the buying and selling o or over electronic systems such as the Internet and other . The amount of trade conducted electronically has grown extraordinary since the spread of the Internet. A wide variety of commerce is conducted in this way, spurring and drawing on innovations in , , , (EDI), systems, and automated data collection systems. Modern electronic commerce typically uses the at least at some point in the transaction's lifecycle, although it can encompass a wider range of technologies such as as well.
A small percentage of electronic commerce is conducted entirely electronically for "virtual" items such as access to premium content on a website, but most electronic commerce involves the transportation of physical items in some way. Online retailers are sometimes known as e-tailers and online retail is known as e-tail. Almost all big retailers have electronic commerce presence in the World Wide Webs. Some well known names are Amazon.com, eBay.com. Most of big e-tailers are doing business worldwide.
Electronic commerce that is conducted between businesses is referred to as or B2B. B2B can be open to all interested parties or limited to specific, pre-qualified participants
E-commerce or electronic commerce is generally considered to be the sales aspect of. It also consists of the exchange of data to facilitate the financing and payment aspects of the business transactions.