Everybody knows what an handwritten signature is, and although the signature requirement with reference to contract law may vary from one country to another, we can say, generally speaking, that by handwriting our name at the bottom of a contract we accept the terms of the document. We can use our signature for many other purposes: to issue an order, to file a request, to sign a love letter, etc. and the legal implications of each signature is rather different, however the concept of signature is basically the same. By signing our name at the bottom of a piece of paper we indicate that the document is produced by whoever signed it, with all legal implication attributed to such an act by applicable law.
In theory we can have different handwritten signatures for various purposes, we may initial certain documents and use full signature in other documents, however the process and the result is not different. In practice, in the paper world we basically have one definition of signature, which attributes the document to the signing party, and whose effect depends on the type of document, applicable law, etc.
Handwritten signatures have not always had this importance, and in the past the same legal implications was given to official seals, rather than to signatures, and a residue of this has remained in some public law legislation as well as in some more traditional countries.
We can basically say that as soon as writing became common, handwritten signatures became the main method of attributing a document to an individual. At the same time, most legislations considerably disfavoured oral agreements and, as such, signing in writing a contract has become the primary procedure to evidence that each party to a contract was in agreement with it.
Because on the central role of signatures, a special set of rules has been developed in every country to deal with issues such as authentication of signatures, forgery of signatures, etc.. All those rules imply the existence of an handwriting.
The tradition scenario is quite difficult to apply to digital signatures and, basically, we have to start the entire process all over again.
First of all, we have to identify what is the best method for attributing the digital document to a person. This implies that we must be reasonably sure that the process provides some inherent assurance against forgery and frauds. In the paper world the assurance was given by the supposed uniqueness of every person's handwriting, in the digital world we have to decide about a "unique" element that will have the same, or a similar, function.
For example, I normally type my name when sending an e-mail, however this is not sufficient to prove undoubtedly that the e-mail comes from me, as anybody else may type in my name. We may decide that the circumstance that the transmission comes from my computer and that I am the only one to access my computer is sufficient evidence, or require that I encrypt the message with a code known to me and to the recipient, or that I use a signature verified by a cryptographic algorithm disclosed to the recipient, or certified by a third party, or that I use a biometric key, just to mention a few alternatives. The role of the regulation is that of identifying the requirements that, when met, qualify an apparently incoherent electroning signal as my signature and, subsequently, that of deciding what are the legal effects of that electronic signal. Later on the regulation should also identify rules to deal with forgery problems, however we are still far from this point being reasonably addressed.
Friday, February 15, 2008
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
1 comment:
I do wanted to know the exact difference between handwritten signatures and digital signatures. And finally today I found this article in which you have listed the most significant points of difference. Thanks.
electronic signatures
Post a Comment